High Prairie Grain-Free Roasted Bison & Venison vs Prey Angus Beef Limited Ingredient
High Prairie Grain-Free Roasted Bison & Venison
$6.78/dayPrey Angus Beef Limited Ingredient
$6.78/dayThe short answer
Both Taste of the Wild and Diamond Naturals are made by Diamond Pet Foods, in the same facilities, by the same company. Taste of the Wild is the premium-positioned brand with grain-free recipes and exotic protein sources. Diamond Naturals is the value-tier sister brand with grain-inclusive recipes at a lower price point. They share more than they differ.
At a glance
| Taste of the Wild | Diamond Naturals | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand tier | Premium grain-free | Value premium grain-inclusive |
| Parent company | Diamond Pet Foods | Diamond Pet Foods |
| Made in | USA (Diamond facilities) | USA (Diamond facilities) |
| Grain-free / inclusive | Grain-free primary | Grain-inclusive primary |
| Protein sources | Bison, venison, wild boar, salmon | Lamb, chicken, beef |
| Marketing positioning | Wild prey / ancestral | Value premium |
| Recall history | Notable (shared facility issues) | Notable (shared facility issues) |
| Best for | Grain-free at moderate price | Multi-dog households on budget |
Who each one is actually for
Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Roasted Bison & Venison fits owners who:
- Want grain-free recipes with novel proteins at a moderate price
- Like the wild-prey marketing positioning
- Prefer the broader Diamond Pet Foods retail distribution
- Are committed to grain-free feeding (with the FDA DCM caveat in mind)
Diamond Naturals Adult Lamb Meal & Rice fits owners who:
- Want a value-tier kibble at well below premium pricing
- Prefer grain-inclusive recipes
- Trust the Diamond Pet Foods manufacturing process (and have read the recall history)
- Need to feed a multi-dog household on a tighter budget
The verdict
Taste of the Wild for owners who want grain-free recipes with novel proteins at a more accessible price than ultra-premium brands. Diamond Naturals for owners who want a value-tier option from a manufacturer they trust. Both come with the Diamond Pet Foods recall history, which has been a real concern in the past and is worth knowing about.
Common questions
Is Taste of the Wild made by Diamond Pet Foods?
Yes. Taste of the Wild is owned by Diamond Pet Foods and produced in Diamond's facilities. Diamond Naturals is also a Diamond Pet Foods brand. The two share manufacturing infrastructure.
Has Taste of the Wild been recalled?
Yes, including a 2012 salmonella recall that was part of a broader Diamond Pet Foods facility issue. The brand was also named in the FDA's 2019 grain-free DCM update. Both incidents are part of the public record and worth understanding before buying.
Is Diamond Naturals a good budget dog food?
For value-tier kibble, yes. Diamond Naturals offers higher protein and named meats than most grocery-store brands at similar pricing. The trade-off is the recall history of the manufacturer, which is real and which buyers should weigh.
Should I switch from Taste of the Wild given the DCM concerns?
For healthy dogs, the cautious move is to switch to a grain-inclusive recipe from a brand that runs feeding trials. This isn't an emergency but it is the conservative position. The grain-free DCM guide has the longer framework.